If you’re a homeowner looking for cash without monthly payments, you may have come across Home Equity Agreements (HEAs) as an alternative to traditional Home Equity Lines of Credit (HELOCs).
But how do they really work? Are they better than a HELOC? And what happens if your home appreciates—especially due to renovations?
In this guide, we’ll cover:
✅ How HEAs work
✅ A step-by-step example of repayment
✅ Key differences between HEAs and HELOCs
✅ What happens if your home appreciates?
✅ What to watch out for in HEA contracts
What Is a Home Equity Agreement (HEA)?
A Home Equity Agreement (HEA) is a financing tool where a company gives you a lump sum of cash in exchange for a percentage of your home’s future appreciation.
Unlike a HELOC or home equity loan, an HEA has:
- No monthly payments
- No interest
- A lump sum repayment due later, usually when you sell or refinance
Most HEAs last 10 to 30 years, but repayment is due when a triggering event occurs, such as:
- Selling the home
- Refinancing the mortgage
- Reaching the end of the HEA term
Since there’s no monthly obligation, this appeals to homeowners who need cash but don’t want an added loan payment. However, it comes at a cost—you share a percentage of future appreciation with the HEA provider.
How Do HEAs Work? (Example Calculation)
Let’s say:
- Your home is worth $100,000 today.
- You take $10,000 in an HEA (10% of your home’s value).
- The HEA provider takes a 16% share of your home’s future appreciation.
- 5 years later, you sell your home for $150,000.
What You Owe:
1️⃣ Original amount received: $10,000
2️⃣ HEA provider’s share of appreciation (16% of $50,000): $8,000
3️⃣ Total repayment amount: $18,000
Even though you only took $10,000 upfront, you end up paying $18,000 because the HEA provider gets a share of your home’s appreciation.
📌 Key Takeaway: If your home appreciates significantly, the HEA repayment amount can be much higher than the initial cash you received.
HEA vs. HELOC: Which One Is Better?
Many homeowners compare HEAs to HELOCs to decide which financing option works best. Here’s a side-by-side comparison:
Key Differences Between HEAs and HELOCs
| Feature | Home Equity Agreement (HEA) | Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Payments? | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
| Interest Charged? | ❌ No interest | ✅ Variable or fixed rates |
| Repayment Method | Lump sum at sale/refinance | Monthly payments over time |
| Credit Score Needed? | Flexible | Typically 620+ |
| Best For: | Homeowners who need cash without monthly payments | Borrowers who want flexibility and lower total cost |
| Risk | Must share appreciation | Risk of foreclosure if payments aren’t made |
🚨 Biggest Risk of an HEA: If your home appreciates a lot, you may owe much more than the amount you initially borrowed.
✅ Best for Short-Term Borrowing: A HELOC is usually cheaper if you can handle monthly payments.
✅ Best for No-Monthly-Payment Cash Access: An HEA makes sense if you don’t want debt but can handle a higher payout later.
What If My Home Appreciates Because of Renovations?
A huge concern with HEAs is whether homeowners must share home value increases caused by renovations.
If you make major improvements (e.g., adding a bedroom or remodeling the kitchen), will the HEA provider still take a percentage of that added value?
🔍 It depends on your HEA contract.
Some providers:
✅ Exclude home improvement-related appreciation (but you must document costs with receipts and permits).
❌ Still take a percentage of the total value increase, even if it was due to renovations.
Example:
- You take $10,000 in an HEA when your home is $100,000.
- You spend $20,000 adding a new bedroom, and now the home is worth $150,000.
- If the HEA does not exclude home improvement appreciation, you may still owe a share of the full $50,000 increase—even though $20,000 of it came from your addition!
📌 Tip: Before signing, ask the HEA provider:
1️⃣ How do you handle home improvements?
2️⃣ What documentation do I need to exclude my renovations from appreciation calculations?
3️⃣ Do I need an appraisal before and after improvements?
HEA Pros & Cons
✅ Pros of a Home Equity Agreement
- No monthly payments (cash without debt).
- Easier to qualify for than a HELOC (low credit score OK).
- Flexible use of funds (no restrictions).
- Can help avoid foreclosure for cash-strapped homeowners.
❌ Cons of a Home Equity Agreement
- You give up part of your home’s appreciation.
- Expensive if home values rise significantly.
- Early repayment penalties may apply.
- Some HEAs take a cut of home improvements’ value increase.
🚀 Pro Tip: If you expect your home value to rise quickly, an HEA may cost you more than a traditional HELOC.
Is an HEA Right for You?
💰 An HEA may be a good fit if:
✅ You need cash but don’t want loan payments.
✅ Your credit score makes it hard to qualify for a HELOC.
✅ You’re planning to sell your home within a few years.
⚠️ An HEA may NOT be ideal if:
❌ You expect significant home appreciation and want to keep all the gains.
❌ You don’t want to give up future equity.
❌ You need long-term financing and a cheaper borrowing option.
Final Thoughts: HEA or HELOC?
Before signing an HEA, read the contract carefully and understand the trade-offs. If you’re considering a Home Equity Agreement, compare different providers, ask about renovation exclusions, and consider whether a HELOC might be the better option for your situation.
📩 Have questions about HEAs or HELOCs? Contact us today for expert guidance on choosing the right financing option for your home!
📢 Share this post with anyone considering tapping into their home equity!
0 Comments